Social or Economic Class? False Dichotomies, Reductionism and Abstract Categories

Papagiannaki, Eleni and Philp, Bruce and Arntsen, Alexandra (2020) Social or Economic Class? False Dichotomies, Reductionism and Abstract Categories. Working Paper 2. Centre for Applied Finance and Economics.

Preview

Text 20200225_CAFE_WP2_Papagiannaki_Philp_Arntsen.pdf - Submitted Version Download (759kB)

Abstract

Against the backdrop of socio-economic conflict, this paper analyses a number of approaches to classes in the economics, political economy and sociology literatures. Our argument is structured into two themes which consider: (i) class and individualism; (ii) social and economic classes. We also consider deductive and inductive class analyses within these themes. This typology is used to classify the methodological approaches of scholars from a variety of traditions, thereby providing a basis for assessing their congruence, and the plausibility of developing an integrated perspective on class, spanning heterodox economics and sociology. Initial discussion considers classical political economy and its Marxian derivatives, including Lenin’s criteria for categorising classes, and relatively recent approaches derived from economics, political economy (in the Marxian tradition), and sociology. Based on our analysis of the two themes identified we argue that the abstract pairs of categories — class-individual, social-economic — should not be falsely dichotomised. In addition, we argue that a reductionist approach to class (be it economic or micro-reductionism) only provides a partial account, and fails to capture the complexity of class in relation to other forms of social stratification.

Item Type:	Monograph (Working Paper)
Identification Number:	2
Dates:	Date Event 3 February 2020 Published Online
Subjects:	CAH15 - social sciences > CAH15-02 - economics > CAH15-02-01 - economics CAH15 - social sciences > CAH15-01 - sociology, social policy and anthropology > CAH15-01-02 - sociology CAH20 - historical, philosophical and religious studies > CAH20-01 - history and archaeology > CAH20-01-01 - history
Divisions:	Business School > Accountancy, Finance and Economics > Centre for Accountancy Finance and Economics Business School > Accountancy, Finance and Economics Business School > Management, Business and Marketing Law and Social Sciences > Criminology and Sociology > Criminology Law and Social Sciences > Criminology and Sociology > Sociology
Depositing User:	Eleni Papagiannaki
Date Deposited:	02 Mar 2020 10:54
Last Modified:	04 Aug 2025 13:00
URI:	https://www.open-access.bcu.ac.uk/id/eprint/8964

Actions (login required)

View Item